17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (2024)

We have almost two dozen answers for all those wondering what to do with fresh tomatoes. The fresh tomato recipe ideas ahead, from tomato soup and sandwiches to tomato salads and drinks, combine classics with innovative ways to use the plump garden staple.

01of 17

Heirloom Tomato and Green Bean Salad

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (1)

Why toss together several picnic salads when you can combine everyone's favorites in one rainbow-hued feast? This heirloom tomato recipe is like a Caprese salad, pasta salad, and bean salad all in one. Fresh mint and parsley perk up the already-vibrant blend of heirloom tomatoes, blanched green beans, tender couscous, and crunchy jicama. Try it as a side or top with grilled shrimp, chicken, or salmon to make this the meal.

02of 17

Tomato Pizza Rolls

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (2)

Say, "see ya!" to that standard slice. (Just for today!) This fresh tomato recipe idea combines everything you love about fresh-baked bread and pizza in one handheld package. Cherry tomatoes burst with sweet-tangy brightness once roasted atop the puffy bread rolls.

03of 17

Fresh Tomato Soup

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (3)

You're just 30 minutes away from pairing this tomato recipe with your go-to grilled cheese sandwich. Garden-fresh tomatoes star in this creamy tomato soup. A drizzle of honey and fresh basil add layers of light sweetness to the timeless comfort food.

04of 17

Summer Tomato Salad

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (4)

Come peak season, heirloom tomato recipes like this will inspire you to let the tomatoes step into the spotlight. Zero cooking is required. Just make the quick-pickled red onions, slice the tomatoes, and toss it all together with a homemade white balsamic dressing and serve it in a patio-friendly bowl (like you'll find in this Better Homes & Gardens 12-Piece Eco-Friendly Bamboo Melamine Dinnerware Set, $26, Walmart). Summer side dishes don't get much fresher than this.

Bucatini with Shrimp and Spicy Cherry Tomato Pan Sauce

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (5)

Seafood fans will definitely want to give this cherry tomato recipe a twirl. Sauté sweet cherry tomatoes in garlic to create a summery sauce that's ideal for tossing with shrimp and pasta. Crushed red pepper adds a pleasant hint of spice.

24 Quick Summer Dinners

06of 17

Tiny Tomato Pie

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (6)

As shepherd's pies and pot pies prove, pies aren't always sweet. When you're wondering what to do with fresh tomatoes, you can't go wrong with this savory pie that calls for piling tiny tomatoes onto a feta and Parmesan crust. As they bake, the tomatoes melt into the tender, flaky crust.

07of 17

Two Tomato Bruschetta

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (7)

Invite this roma tomato recipe to the party! Your next co*cktail party or picnic, that is, and each batch can be ready in just 15 minutes. Small roma tomatoes are the perfect size for crunchy toasts, and their tangy flavor complements salty feta and sun-dried tomatoes for an irresistible appetizer. Plate them on a tray (like this Better Homes & Garden Galvanized Rectangle Bed Tray, $17, Walmart) so you can easily transport them to your outdoor dining table.

08of 17

Spicy Tomato Gin and Tonic

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (8)

Sip on a gin and tonic with a kick! If you like savory drinks like vegetable juice or Bloody Mary co*cktails, then this is the cherry tomato recipe to try next happy hour. The spicy drink, spiked with hot sauce and Worcestershire sauce, will entertain with its unique flavor and colorful look.

Tomato-Edamame Grilled Cheese

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (9)

This fresh tomato recipe is not the standard grilled cheese you remember from childhood. Ripe tomatoes and a garlicky soybean spread take the comfort food sandwich to new flavor heights. The leftover spread is a delicious dip or dressing for fresh veggies.

10of 17

Grilled Ribeye Steaks with Smoked Tomatoes

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (10)

This charred-just-enough heirloom tomato recipe is layered with such rich, smoky flavors, they really stand up to the savory grilled steaks. Try this with vine-ripened tomatoes when they are inexpensive and plentiful. At season's end, try smoking your green tomatoes, too.

11of 17

Zoodle Bowls with Tomato Sauce and Sausage

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (11)

When fresh tomatoes are in season, ditch the jarred marinara. This fresh tomato recipe puts a huge harvest (4 pounds!) to tasty work in a freezer-friendly, sweet pepper-infused sauce. While you can use it over regular pasta, we prefer this Paleo version made with zoodles for its double dose of summer produce picks. Savory chicken sausage slices round out the restaurant-quality "pasta" dinner.

12of 17

Avocado Pesto-Stuffed Tomatoes

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (12)

Three appetizer hits join forces in this cherry tomato recipe: pesto, avocado, and tomatoes. But this one-bite treat requires no toast, cook time, or cilantro (welcome news for the cilantro-averse!). For this easy 18-calorie snack, basil pesto blends with avocado and cream cheese for the smooth, luscious filling for the cherry tomatoes.

13of 17

Shrimp and Tomato Piccata

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (13)

Our goal when we created this fresh tomato recipe idea? Whip up a simple blend of pure flavors in a light seafood piccata that can be savored over cooked pasta or zucchini noodles. Luscious tomatoes, earthy string beans, and savory tender shrimp shine under the subtle lemon and caper sauce.

14of 17

Pork and Potatoes with Tomato Relish

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (14)

Thinly sliced tomatoes, onion, and vinaigrette combine in a light and juicy topper for this classic meat-and-potatoes dinner that can be on your table 20 minutes from now. The simple relish brightens the flavor of pork, but it could work with almost any meat (any cut of steak tastes great, too!).

15of 17

Chicken, Tomato, and Cucumber Salad

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (15)

Gluten-free, low in carbs, yet full of flavor, this fresh tomato recipe is one of the most popular on our site. The 25-minute Mediterranean-style salad will change the way you think about quick chicken dinners. (In other words, this is far from the plain ol' chicken breasts!) Fresh tomatoes and cucumbers sing under simple seasonings like thyme and black pepper, and a bit of salty, creamy feta help this healthy entrée feel like a treat.

16of 17

Mama's Spicy Meatballs with Fresh Tomato Sauce

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (16)

Bring home the flavors of Italy! You'll feel like you've been transported to a nonna's (aka Italian grandma) dinner table in Rome once you taste this traditional tomato sauce recipe: sautéed garlic, fresh roma tomatoes, and a splash of red wine. The roma tomato recipe pairs beautifully with our spicy meatball recipe. Buon appetito!

17of 17

Pan-Fried Chicken with Tomato Jam

View Recipe

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (17)

Fried chicken gets a less-messy, lower-calorie makeover in this roma tomato recipe. The flavorful stove-top chicken topped with a plum-tomato jam makes an ideal weeknight supper for those who crave fast food and those who are trying to eat a healthful diet. Wilted spinach and creamy polenta round out the meal.

17 Garden-Fresh Tomato Recipes That Showcase This Garden Staple (2024)

FAQs

What can I do with lots of fresh tomatoes? ›

6 Creative Ways to Use Up Extra Tomatoes
  1. Cheese Shelled Tacos & Salsa.
  2. Sweet & Spicy Salsa.
  3. Bell Pepper Salsa Fresca.
  4. Tomato Soup & Baked Mini Grilled Cheese.
  5. Creamy Tomato & Bell Pepper Soup.
  6. Tomato & Basil Soup.
  7. Cherry Tomato Bruschetta.
  8. Feta Bruschetta Chicken.
Jul 27, 2020

What can I do with too many tomatoes from my garden? ›

Here are several options for what to do with an excess of tomatoes: Canning or Preserving: Consider canning or preserving your tomatoes to enjoy them throughout the year. You can make tomato sauce, tomato paste, tomato jam, or canned whole tomatoes.

What can I do with 5 pounds of fresh tomatoes? ›

  1. Gazpacho.
  2. Slow and low oven roasted tomatoes (perfect topping for just about anything)
  3. Stuffed tomatoes (endless options here: couscous, rice, ground meat/poultry and cheese, chicken/tuna/egg salads)
  4. Baked tomatoes (halve, sprinkle with Parmesan and breadcrumb, and a spritz of oil)
  5. Tomato jam.
  6. Salsa or pico de gallo.
Jun 25, 2020

How long do tomatoes last in the fridge? ›

Storing and Handling Guidelines

Tomatoes stored at refrigeration temperatures below 41 °F will have approximate shelf life of 5 days. Tomatoes stored at temperatures under 75 °F will have approximate shelf life of 1 to 2 days. Storing tomatoes above 75° F is not recommended.

Can I freeze fresh tomatoes? ›

Tomatoes may be frozen raw or cooked, whole, sliced, chopped, or puréed. Tomatoes do not need to be blanched before freezing. Frozen tomatoes are best used in cooked foods such as soups, sauces and stews as they become mushy when they're thawed.

Do fresh tomatoes last longer in the fridge or on the counter? ›

Ripe Tomatoes

And unless you're eating them immediately, ripe, locally grown tomatoes will also last longer in the fridge; eat within a few days. Store ripe tomatoes in your fridge stress-free and enjoy them within a couple days of purchasing.

What not to do with tomato plants? ›

8 common tomato growing mistakes that can ruin your harvest – plus how to avoid them
  1. Choosing the wrong variety.
  2. Getting the planting timing wrong.
  3. Not planting deep enough.
  4. Inconsistent watering.
  5. Planting in the wrong spot.
  6. Not fertilizing plants.
  7. Not supporting plants.
  8. Not pruning tomatoes.
Apr 7, 2023

Should I water tomatoes once or twice a day? ›

Water newly planted tomatoes well to make sure soil is moist and ideal for growing. Early in the growing season, watering plants daily in the morning. As temperatures increase, you might need to water tomato plants twice a day. Garden tomatoes typically require 1-2 inches of water a week.

What happens if you plant tomatoes too close to each other? ›

Tomato plants require a good amount of these resources, so if they're planted closely together, they will compete and likely all lose. Low Production – Even if tomato plants growing closely together survive, they may not produce as many tomatoes as they could have if properly spaced.

What to do with 20 tomatoes? ›

  1. Slow-roast them. This is a VERY popular exit strategy for our CSA masters. ...
  2. Dehydrate them. Once again, I would recommend this step for Romas, globes, or cherry tomatoes — not heirlooms! ...
  3. Freeze them. ...
  4. Make Marinara Sauce. ...
  5. Make Salsa. ...
  6. Tomato Purée. ...
  7. Make Tomato Juice.

How many tomatoes can you put in a 5 gallon bucket? ›

The Benefits of Using 5-Gallon Buckets

The standard size of these buckets allows for at least two tomato plants per bucket. This makes them an efficient use of space in small gardens or balcony spaces.

Can you crush fresh tomatoes and freeze them? ›

Crush the tomatoes by hand or in a food processor or blender, depending on the consistency you're going for. Add the crushed tomatoes to an airtight, freezer-safe container, and transfer it to the freezer.

How do you tell if a tomato has gone bad? ›

Bad tomatoes also tend to leak fluid. If you pick up a tomato and notice that there is fluid underneath it, then it has gone bad. Feel – if a tomato is soft or mushy when given a light squeeze, it has gone bad. Smell – if you find that a tomato is producing a bitter or putrid smell, then it has gone bad.

Why do cherry tomatoes say do not refrigerate? ›

The standard rule is to keep tomatoes out of the refrigerator. It all comes down to science: Tomatoes contain an enzyme that reacts to cold temperatures, causing the cell membranes to break down and leaving you with a piece of fruit that's mushy and mealy.

How do I freeze tomatoes? ›

All you have to do is wash and dry the tomatoes. At this point, you may want to hull the tomatoes to remove the woody stem and core if you plan to use the tomatoes whole in months to come. Next, store the tomatoes in a zip-top bag and force out as much air as possible before lying them flat in the freezer.

What is the best way to preserve fresh tomatoes? ›

Best Ways to Preserve Tomatoes
  1. Freezing is the easiest to way to preserve cherry tomatoes.
  2. Drying preserves the colors and flavors of juicy heirloom varieties.
  3. Partially dehydrated and frozen half-dried tomatoes can be used like fresh ones.
  4. The tanginess of green tomatoes is best preserved in chutney.
Jul 31, 2020

How do you preserve fresh grown tomatoes? ›

A: The best way to store fresh tomatoes so that they last is to pick them at the breaker stage (shown on the left) … store at 50°F (10°C) … and out of direct sunlight. Move them to a place at room temperature a few days before you want to use them.

How do you store fresh tomatoes long term? ›

To store the tomatoes in the refrigerator or freezer, place them in a zip-top bag and squeeze any extra air out. Put them in the refrigerator for up to a month or stick them in the freezer. To store tomatoes in oil, sterilize a mason jar by boiling it for 10 minutes.

How do you preserve fresh tomatoes for a year? ›

Canning Tomatoes

It's best to remove the skins from the tomatoes before canning, and it's important to use new jars, as used jars might not seal properly upon processing. Once processed, home canned tomatoes can often last as long as one year if stored in a cool, dry, and dark space.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6063

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.