Why Does Lamb Taste So Weird? (2024)

UPR has a state-wide audience, so here at Bread and Butter we try not to fixate on specific food venues. Because why would we torture you folks in Richfield and Vernal with the news that there’s a restaurant near here that serves mouthwatering Barbacoa quesadillas with hand-made tortillas cooked to a toasty crisp, melt-in-your-mouth shredded pork, dark brown candy-like caramelized onions and a side of tangy and colorful jalapeno sauce. That wouldn’t be nice.

But today I do need to mention one place specifically. It’s an Indian restaurant here in Logan – Tandoori Oven. I mention this place because I wanted to talk about a dish I had there-- lamb tikka masala. You may know that tikka masala is curried meat, slow cooked in a spicy sauce with onions, bell peppers, tomatoes and cream. It’s delicious. But I was pondering last week why lamb tastes so weird. Not just lamb at Tandoori Oven, but all lamb. It’s just a weird tasting food.

Some places in the world treat lamb like a staple, but we tend not to eat much lamb in Utah, and it can be hard to find on menus or at grocery stores. If you’ve never had lamb before, this type of meat can taste … gamey? Maybe? It’s not even really a taste, I realized, as I was scooping it up with my garlic naan … as much as something your mouth just kind of senses. The first time I had lamb, it was actually mutton (which is meat from older sheep). I was 12 years old, and the taste literally made me gag. The earthy flavor was overwhelming to my somewhat inexperienced palate.

But now I like it ... kind of. I like it and hate it, both at the same time. I don’t crave lamb the same way I crave fresh peaches or dark chocolate, but when I eat it, there’s this bizarre attraction to the flavor that keeps me going … like not being able to look away from gory road kill.

It’s the same way I feel about goat cheese. In fact, goat cheese and lamb both have that same peculiar taste. It’s tart and rotten, meaty and pungent. It’s (obviously) hard to describe. And not just for me. Not much has been written about lamb’s weirdness … besides the science behind it. That “gamey” taste, for lack of a better term, lies in the meat’s fat, and is a result of the animal’s diet.

What it all comes down to is a particular type of fatty acid that lambs have and beef and chicken don’t. It's called branched-chain fatty acid. This is something that humans can detect at really low levels. Gaminess is ambiguous because it is largely detected by the receptors of our harder to describe fifth taste, umami. … which is why it hardly feels like a taste at all. Animals that are grass (rather than grain) fed, or that eat a wild diet will come across as more gamey. The same effect of diet is even more obvious in the milk of nursing females … which is why I pick it up in the goat cheese.

But the word “gamey” really does gets a bad rap. It’s definitely a stronger, more wild flavor. But blue cheese is strong. And huckleberries taste wild. If I had grown up eating lamb and drinking goat’s milk, would it have taken so long to enjoy it?

My husband says I analyze my food too much, and I probably do. Because even though I can’t quite describe or decipher the taste of lamb, I’m still going back for more.

Why Does Lamb Taste So Weird? (2024)

FAQs

Why does lamb have a weird taste? ›

That “gamey” taste, for lack of a better term, lies in the meat's fat, and is a result of the animal's diet. What it all comes down to is a particular type of fatty acid that lambs have and beef and chicken don't.

How do you explain the taste of lamb? ›

Lamb meat has a distinctive flavor that sets it apart from other meats, such as beef and pork. While beef has a more robust and earthy flavor, lamb offers a unique combination of tenderness, juiciness, and a slight hint of gaminess.

Why is some lamb tasteless? ›

These are very young lambs that have only eaten their mother's milk and never had grass before being slaughtered. The meat is pale and would be considered lacking in flavour by many people used to grass fed lamb.

What makes lamb taste better? ›

The big, bold Lamb flavor goes well with spices like coriander seeds, cumin, curry powder, harissa paste, garlic, rosemary, oregano, thyme, black pepper, chilly flakes, and mint. Spices compliment Lamb, but it also holds its flavor with just salt and pepper.

How to get gamey taste out of lamb? ›

The distinct game flavor of either birds or animals will be milder after soaking the meat overnight in the refrigerator in either a salt or vinegar solution.

What is a gamey taste? ›

"It means a stronger, wilder flavor," Toups added. "If you're used to eating domesticated animals, then you can taste the difference right away. The animal is often stronger, and the protein leaner in fat. If you were to kill a wild elk, it would be nearly fat-free.

What is the least gamey lamb? ›

American Lamb:

This breed is the largest in size and many say is the highest in quality and consistency. American lamb has grain in its diet and thus tastes less “gamey” compared to imported lamb which is typically grass fed. It is also the most expensive available.

Is lamb meat chewy? ›

No matter how well your Lamb is cooked. If you cut it incorrectly, you'll end up with tough, chewy meat — even if you cooked it perfectly! The advice is always to cut the meat across the grain.

Why do I not feel well after eating lamb? ›

Meat Intolerance Explained

Meat intolerance refers to your body's difficulty in digesting meat (beef, lamb, and pork) and experiencing adverse physical reactions to them. This condition, while not life-threatening, could be a sign of other issues such as irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) or Crohn's disease.

How old are lambs when they are slaughtered? ›

Lambs are sent to slaughter at the very young age of 10 weeks to one year – the average age of death is six to seven months, even though they could live up to 12 years old – that's just 1/24th of their natural life expectancy.

When you eat lamb, is it a baby? ›

Lamb meat is simply meat from young sheep under one year of age. Mutton is the meat of mature sheep, harvested between 2 to 3 years of age to produce mutton cuts. To go a bit deeper, there are two Lamb sub-categories based on the specific age of lamb at harvest: Baby Lamb – Refers to lamb meat aged 6 to 10 weeks old.

What is the tastiest lamb? ›

The best Lamb cut award goes to Lamb Loin Chops, hands down the best balance of flavor, tenderness, and value for money. These tasty mini T-bone shaped morsels have a wonderful buttery fat cap and extremely tender meat. Loin Chops are easily and quickly cooked in the pan and are reasonably priced.

Is lamb worth eating? ›

Being rich in high-quality protein and many vitamins and minerals, lamb can be an excellent component of a healthy diet.

Is lamb tastier than goat? ›

Taste: Goat meat tends to be milder and slightly sweeter when compared to lamb meat. Lamb meat is richer and tastes gamey. Nutrition: Goat tends to have more protein than mutton or lamb. Regarding fat content, lamb has more of it than goat meat.

Why is lamb meat gamey? ›

First of all, lamb tastes like lamb because it has a fatty acid that beef doesn't. It gives the meat its distinctive gamey flavour. You either love it, or you don't. Lamb is also one of those farmed animals that lives a pretty good, ethical life before we get it.

Why don't Americans eat more lamb? ›

Because so few states in America initially raised sheep, the cost for lamb meat would be higher than other meats. This cost barrier prevented many Americans from even trying lamb meat. This initial barrier has made it difficult for lamb meat to gain popularity in the US.

Why does lamb taste musky? ›

Our Everyday Life explains that the gamey smell comes from the fat of the animal and the myoglobin in the meat. Myoglobin is the red liquid that comes from meat that is often confused with blood. Marinating the lamb in milk will draw out and settle some of its less pleasant smells and flavors.

Why does lamb taste minty? ›

Mint is rich with branched-chain ketones, which are chemically related to lamb's BCFAs and have similar, though not identical, aromas. This means, according to the theory of food pairing, that lamb and mint are a scientific match.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 6000

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.